One of Google’s Gemini-powered photo features is MIA in Texas and Illinois. The company confirmed to Engadget that Ask Photos is currently unavailable in the two states. It didn’t say why. Google Photos’ Conversational Editing is reportedly missing in those states, too.
“The ability to ask Photos to edit your images is not available to users in Texas and Illinois at this time,” Google’s statement to Engadget reads. “We are working to determine how to make Ask Photos available to more users.”
As for why that is, we don’t have confirmation. But the Houston Chronicle, which first reported the news, pointed to a pair of lawsuit settlements as a likely culprit. In 2022, Google settled an Illinois class action suit over Google Photos data privacy concerns for $200 million. Earlier this year, it settled one with Texas for $1.4 billion over collecting user data without permission.
The common theme in both settlements was biometric data collection. Lo and behold, both of the missing AI features require “face grouping” to be turned on. That Google Photos feature uses automated facial recognition to cluster pictures of the same person.
The tricky part comes when state laws require informed consent for data collection. 9to5Google notes that only the photographer — and not the many subjects of their pictures — have typically agreed to Google’s terms and conditions. That creates a head-spinning legal conundrum that could have easily led Google to play it safe.
Ask Google Photos lets you type or speak queries about your picture library. For example, you could say, “What are all the cities I visited last year?” or “Show me the best photo from each national park I’ve visited.” Meanwhile, Conversational Editing lets you tweak images using natural language. It launched with the Pixel 10 series in August and expanded to other Android phones in September.
